News Summary
A Beaufort County judge has ruled not to dismiss a defamation lawsuit filed by Hilton Head Island Middle School teacher Mardy Burleson against local parent David Cook. The lawsuit arises from Cook’s social media claims suggesting Burleson was involved in ‘grooming’ students via a classroom survey on preferred pronouns. The ruling could set a precedent for similar defamation cases amidst rising political tensions regarding educational content in South Carolina’s public schools.
Beaufort County, South Carolina – A Beaufort County judge has ruled not to dismiss a defamation lawsuit filed by Hilton Head Island Middle School teacher Mardy Burleson against local parent David Cook. The lawsuit stems from Cook’s social media claims that Burleson was engaging in “grooming” students through a classroom survey concerning preferred pronouns. The ruling was issued by Judge Robert Bonds last Thursday, with Cook’s motion for dismissal being denied after careful consideration.
The controversy began when Burleson administered a classroom survey that included questions about students’ preferred pronouns and their comfort levels in using them publicly. Cook’s child, a student in Burleson’s class, leaked details of the survey to him, prompting Cook to raise concerns with the school principal about its appropriateness. In response, Burleson modified the survey to avoid further conflict.
The situation escalated significantly in June 2023 when Cook gained media attention for throwing bags of chicken feed at members of the school board during a contentious meeting. This act was part of his protest against the board’s management of controversial books being discussed for potential removal from school libraries.
Burleson’s lawsuit includes allegations that Cook’s statements likened her to a “pervert” and accused her of “indoctrinating” students, which she argues has inflicted substantial emotional distress and harmed her reputation as an educator. In addition to Cook, the lawsuit lists several defendants, including former Beaufort County Council member Michael Covert and Republican state representative Thomas Beach, who are alleged to have spread false claims through public discussions and social media posts.
This legal action is not an isolated case. It is one of two defamation lawsuits filed by teachers from Hilton Head Island Middle School aimed at community members in response to growing political backlash over classroom content and library books. South Carolina has emerged as the state with the highest number of book bans in public schools, with many of the banned titles linked to the involvement of another Beaufort County parent in a separate defamation lawsuit concerning educational material.
Burleson is receiving legal support from the Equality Legal Action Fund, as she aims not only for damages stemming from the defamation but also to confront the broader narratives and harassment educators face in this charged environment. The judge’s ruling is poised to set a potential precedent regarding how defamation cases linked to school content discussions may be adjudicated in the future.
The case underscores the heightened tensions currently facing educators in South Carolina, particularly around issues relevant to LGBTQ+ topics and educational censorship in public schools. The legal battles occurring in Beaufort County reflect a larger national discourse surrounding the appropriateness of educational content and the rights of parents in influencing what can be taught in schools.
As the legal proceedings continue, further developments in the case may provide increased clarity on how school staff and community members navigate the complex interplay of education, free expression, and the safeguarding of student welfare in today’s politically charged climate.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Defamation Lawsuit Against Teacher Advances in South Carolina
93-Year-Old Woman Fights Developers Over Family Land
Greenpeace Faces $667 Million Defamation Ruling
Former Assistant Principal Sues Beaufort County School District
The Tate Brothers Land in Florida Amid Legal Controversy
Beaufort County Council Changes Meeting Times
Fox Corporation Faces $2.7 Billion Lawsuit from Smartmatic
Settlement Reached in Beaufort County Treasurer Harassment Lawsuit
Beaufort County Teacher Sues Parents for Defamation Amid Controversial Student Survey
Renowned Boeing Whistleblower John Barnett Found Dead in South Carolina
Additional Resources
- Island Packet: Defamation Lawsuit Against Teacher
- Wikipedia: Defamation
- Post and Courier: Hilton Head Teacher Burleson Lawsuit
- Google Search: LGBTQ educators in South Carolina
- WSAV: Second Teacher Sues for Defamation
- Google Scholar: Educational Censorship
- WGN: News Article on Recent Educational Controversies
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Freedom of Expression
- Your Island News: Cook Banned from Beaufort County Schools
- Google News: Beaufort County Education
